I'm referring to this question: Not sure if have to give up priority seat as not sure if lady is pregnant or just plus sized
The basic question there is:
When I can't tell if a lady is pregnant or not, should I offer my seat to her? If so, how?
This was put on hold as primarily opinion-based.
Now, we have another very similar question (possible duplicate?) here: When to Offer Your Seat, which seems to me a broader version of this question. It is well-received (+16/-0) and was never placed on-hold.
I don't see why this is "primarily opinion-based" and the other is not. Anyone want to weigh in?